NEWAll India NCERT Mock Test Series is now live!Take Free Test
| Exercise 1.2

Q1: Prove that 5\sqrt{5} is irrational.

UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION

  • Proof by contradiction: assume 5=ab\sqrt{5} = \dfrac{a}{b} in lowest terms and show 55 divides both aa and bb.

Step 1 — ASSUME RATIONAL, SHOW 5 DIVIDES A

Suppose 5\sqrt{5} is rational. Then 5=ab\sqrt{5} = \dfrac{a}{b} for coprime integers a,ba, b with b≠0b \ne 0.

5 b=a5b2=a2(1)\begin{aligned} \sqrt{5}\, b &= a \\[0.6em] 5b^2 &= a^2 \qquad (1) \end{aligned}

So 55 divides a2a^2, and since 55 is prime, 55 divides aa. Write a=5ca = 5c for some integer cc.

Step 2 — SHOW 5 DIVIDES B: CONTRADICTION

Substitute a=5ca = 5c in (1):

5b2=25c2b2=5c2\begin{aligned} 5b^2 &= 25c^2 \\[0.6em] b^2 &= 5c^2 \end{aligned}

So 55 divides b2b^2, hence 55 divides bb. Now 55 divides both aa and bb, which contradicts aa and bb being coprime. So the assumption is wrong.

ANSWER

Hence, 5\sqrt{5} is irrational.

COMMON MISTAKES

  • Skipping "coprime": the contradiction only works because aa and bb were assumed to have no common factor.
  • Assuming 55 divides aa from 55 divides a2a^2 without justification: must use that 55 is prime.

Was this solution helpful?