Q22: “There is no chord of a circle that is longer than its diameter.” How do you justify this statement?
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
- We need to justify the statement: "There is no chord of a circle that is longer than its diameter."
- Core Class 9 NCERT concepts required:
- Definition of a circle, chord, and diameter.
- Properties of chords and the centre of a circle (Chapter 10: Circles).
- Triangle Inequality Theorem: The sum of the lengths of any two sides of a triangle is greater than the third side.
Step 1 — DEFINE THE TERMS AND SET UP A GEOMETRIC FIGURE
Let there be a circle with centre and radius .
- A chord is a line segment joining any two points on the circle. Let be any chord of the circle.
- A diameter is a chord that passes through the centre of the circle. Let be a diameter of the circle, passing through centre , so that its length is .
Step 2 — CONSTRUCT TRIANGLES USING THE CENTRE OF THE CIRCLE
Join the centre to the endpoints of the chord , forming .
- The length of the side is the radius of the circle, so .
- The length of the side is also the radius of the circle, so .
- The length of the side is the length of the chord.
Step 3 — APPLY THE TRIANGLE INEQUALITY THEOREM
In , by the Triangle Inequality Theorem (which states that the sum of the lengths of any two sides of a triangle is greater than the length of the third side):
Substitute the known lengths of the radii ( and ):
Since the diameter , we have:
Step 4 — CONSIDER THE SPECIAL CASE WHERE THE CHORD PASSES THROUGH THE CENTRE
If the chord happens to pass through the centre , then the points , , and lie on a straight line. In this case, the chord becomes a diameter itself, and its length is exactly equal to the diameter ().
Therefore, for any chord in a circle, its length is either less than or equal to the diameter.
ANSWER
The length of any chord of a circle is always less than or equal to its diameter because the diameter is the longest chord of a circle, passing through the centre.
COMMON MISTAKES
- Assuming all chords are strictly shorter: Students often forget that a diameter is technically also a chord (the longest chord), so equality holds when the chord passes through the centre.
- Using higher-level analytic geometry: Attempting to prove this using the distance formula in a Cartesian coordinate system instead of using pure synthetic geometry and triangle inequalities as taught in Class 9 NCERT.