Q7: If , then . In Questions 8-12, is a positive integer.
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
- The statement provides a logical deduction based on Euclid's Axioms from NCERT Class 9 Chapter 5 (Introduction to Euclid's Geometry).
- Specifically, it illustrates the general notion of equality operations: "If equals are added to equals, the wholes are equal", "If equals are subtracted from equals, the remainders are equal", and fundamentally, "Things which are equal to the same thing are equal to one another" or operating identically on equals gives equal results (multiplication property of equality).
- We need to understand and explain why the statement holds true when given , referring to the algebraic principles and underlying axiomatic foundations introduced in Class 9 mathematics.
Step 1 — STATE THE GIVEN CONDITION
We are given that:
Step 2 — APPLY OPERATION OF EQUALITY
Multiply both sides of the equation by . Since , we can also multiply the left-hand side by and the right-hand side by (because and are equal quantities).
Using Euclid's principle that things which are equal remain equal when operated upon in the same way:
Similarly, since , we can substitute with on the right-hand side, or multiply both sides by :
Combining these results using the transitive property ("Things which are equal to the same thing are equal to one another"): if and , then:
Step 3 — ALTERNATIVE ALGEBRAIC VIEWPOINT
In Class 9 algebra, operating identically on both sides of an equation maintains equality.
Starting with , raising both sides to the same positive integer power (in this case, squaring both sides) yields equal values:
ANSWER
If , multiplying both sides by the equal quantities and respectively (or squaring both sides) results in , which is mathematically valid based on the properties of equality and Euclid's axioms.
COMMON MISTAKES
- Assuming Converse is Always True: Students often mistakenly assume that if , then must always equal . However, could also equal (e.g., , but ). The given statement only goes from to .
- Ignoring Algebraic Rules: Forgetting that whatever operation is performed on one side of an equation must be exactly mirrored on the other side to maintain equality.