Q5: A physical fitness evaluation is being undertaken. The final marks are calculated by combining the marks for strength, flexibility, and agility in the ratio . Rashi has scored , , and . Keerthi has scored , , and respectively. (i) Find out whose total is more without calculating. (ii) What are their final marks?
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
The final marks are weighted sums of the three components with weights 4, 5 and 6. For a student with component marks the total score is . To compare two students without computing the full sums we can use the differences in their component marks multiplied by the corresponding weights. The final marks are obtained by dividing the weighted sum by the sum of the weights, i.e. by .
(i)PART I
Find out whose total is more without calculating.Step 1 — WRITE THE WEIGHTED SUMS
For Rashi: with . For Keerthi: with .
Step 2 — EXPRESS THE DIFFERENCE USING COMPONENT DIFFERENCES
The difference is
Step 3 — INSERT THE KNOWN DIFFERENCES
, , . Hence
Step 4 — INTERPRET THE SIGN OF THE DIFFERENCE
The negative value means that Keerthi’s weighted sum is larger than Rashi’s. Therefore Keerthi has the higher total without computing the full sums.
ANSWER (I)
Keerthi’s total is higher.
(ii)PART II
What are their final marks?Step 1 — COMPUTE THE WEIGHTED SUMS
Rashi: . Keerthi: .
Step 2 — DIVIDE BY THE SUM OF THE WEIGHTS
The sum of the weights is . Thus
Step 3 — SIMPLIFY THE FRACTIONS
Both numerators are divisible by :
ANSWER (II)
Rashi’s final mark is and Keerthi’s final mark is .
COMMON MISTAKES
- Forgetting to divide by the sum of the weights – the weighted sum alone is not the final mark.
- Using the wrong sign when comparing differences – a negative difference indicates the second student has the higher total.
- Misapplying the ratio – the ratio 4:5:6 refers to the weights, not to the raw marks themselves.