Q8: Dorjee has collected 1 litre of water from the Dead Sea! Using the information in the table, answer the following questions. A calculator can be used if necessary.
Water Source Salinity Dead Sea Other seas and oceans Ground water Purified drinking water
Can I drink this?
(i) What is the salinity of the mixture if he mixes 1 litre of water from the Dead Sea with 2 litres of purified drinking water?
(ii) Is it possible to mix water from the Dead Sea and purified drinking water to get a mixture with the salinity of groundwater? Why/Why not? What quantity of purified drinking water should Dorjee mix with 1 litre of water from the Dead Sea to get a mixture having the salinity of groundwater?
(iii) Is it possible to mix water from the Dead Sea and groundwater to get a mixture with the salinity of purified drinking water? Why/Why not? What quantity of groundwater should he mix with 1 litre of water from the Dead Sea to get a mixture having the salinity of purified drinking water?
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
We need to solve a problem involving percentages and mixtures based on the given table of water salinities from NCERT Class 9. Specifically:
- Salinity of Dead Sea
- Salinity of purified drinking water
- Salinity of groundwater
We will use basic arithmetic and linear equations in one variable (standard Class 9 curriculum) to find the mixture salinity and required quantities.
(i)PART I
What is the salinity of the mixture if he mixes 1 litre of water from the Dead Sea with 2 litres of purified drinking water?Step 1 — CALCULATE THE AMOUNT OF SALT IN EACH COMPONENT
Given:
-
Volume of Dead Sea water =
-
Salinity of Dead Sea water =
-
Amount of salt in Dead Sea water =
-
Volume of purified drinking water =
-
Salinity of purified drinking water =
-
Amount of salt in purified drinking water =
Step 2 — CALCULATE TOTAL SALT AND TOTAL VOLUME OF THE MIXTURE
Step 3 — CALCULATE THE PERCENTAGE SALINITY OF THE MIXTURE
ANSWER (I)
The salinity of the mixture is approximately .
(ii)PART II
Is it possible to mix water from the Dead Sea and purified drinking water to get a mixture with the salinity of groundwater? Why/Why not? What quantity of purified drinking water should Dorjee mix with 1 litre of water from the Dead Sea to get a mixture having the salinity of groundwater?Step 1 — ANALYZE FEASIBILITY
Yes, it is possible because the salinity of groundwater () lies between the salinity of the Dead Sea () and purified drinking water (). By adding more purified drinking water, we dilute the high salinity of the Dead Sea water down to .
Step 2 — SET UP THE EQUATION FOR REQUIRED QUANTITY
Let be the volume of purified drinking water (in litres) to be mixed with of Dead Sea water.
- Total volume of mixture =
- Total salt content = Amount of salt in Dead Sea water + Amount of salt in purified drinking water
We want the salinity of the mixture to be equal to the salinity of groundwater, which is , or .
Step 3 — SOLVE THE LINEAR EQUATION
ANSWER (II)
Yes, it is possible because the target salinity lies between the two sources. Dorjee needs to mix approximately of purified drinking water with of Dead Sea water.
(iii)PART III
Is it possible to mix water from the Dead Sea and groundwater to get a mixture with the salinity of purified drinking water? Why/Why not? What quantity of groundwater should he mix with 1 litre of water from the Dead Sea to get a mixture having the salinity of purified drinking water?Step 1 — ANALYZE FEASIBILITY
No, it is not possible. The salinity of purified drinking water () is lower than the salinity of both the Dead Sea () and groundwater (). Mixing two solutions that both have a higher concentration cannot result in a mixture with a lower concentration than both components.
ANSWER (III)
No, it is not possible because both the Dead Sea water and groundwater have a higher salinity than purified drinking water, so mixing them can never dilute the salinity down to .
COMMON MISTAKES
Percentage Conversion Errors: Forgetting to divide percentages by when calculating actual salt quantities.
Logical Flaws in Dilution: Assuming you can dilute a solution using another solution that is also more concentrated than the target.