NEWAll India NCERT Mock Test Series is now live!Take Free Test
| Exercise 11.1

Q5: What happens if we do not include the fifth step in the algorithm above? Give examples where the algorithm will work correctly and where it will fail to work. There is also an important assumption in this algorithm, namely, that we know how to add single digit numbers without counting them out. Typically, any algorithm is built using such basic steps that we assume we can perform directly. The main advantage of this algorithm is that it is much faster than counting explicitly. For instance, if we move from adding 3-digit numbers to adding 4-digit numbers, we have 10 times as many dots to draw and count. On the other hand, if we add the digits right to left, as in the algorithm above, we only have to add 1 more column. Likewise, 5-digit numbers would generate 100 times as many dots as 3-digit numbers, but only 2 more columns to be added. In concrete terms, suppose we can count one dot per second. To count the dots in 33+2733 + 27 would take a minute, to count 334+272334 + 272 would take about ten minutes, while 3347+27293347 + 2729 would take over one hour and forty minutes. On the other hand, suppose we work slowly and carefully and take 15 seconds to add two single digit numbers with a carry. Adding 33+2733 + 27 would take about half a minute, while 334+272334 + 272 would take about 45 seconds, while 3347+27293347 + 2729 would take about one minute. Whenever we provide an algorithm, we also have to justify why it works. Combining the dots and counting the sum is how addition is defined. Why does adding individual digits from right to left result in the sum of the two numbers? The key idea is that we are grouping each number into units, tens, hundreds, … and adding each group separately. Whenever a smaller group, say units, generates a large group of ten, we carry over the newly formed ten to the tens group.

UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION

  • We need to analyze the standard addition algorithm for multi-digit numbers, specifically examining the role of the fifth step (handling the carry).
  • We will provide examples where omitting the carry step leads to incorrect results and where the algorithm works correctly without a carry.
  • We will discuss the foundational assumption of knowing single-digit addition and the efficiency of column-wise right-to-left addition over dot-counting methods.

(a)PART A

What happens if we do not include the fifth step (carrying over to the next place value) in the addition algorithm?

Step 1 — ANALYZE THE ROLE OF THE FIFTH STEP

The fifth step in the standard addition algorithm involves carrying over a group of ten from a lower place value column to the next higher place value column (e.g., carrying a ten from the units column to the tens column when the sum is 1010 or more). If we omit this step, we fail to account for the true place value of the sum in that column.

Step 2 — EXAMINE THE CONSEQUENCE OF OMISSION

Without the carry, only the units digit of the column sum is written down in that place, and the tens digit is completely discarded rather than being added to the adjacent column. This results in a severe underestimation of the total sum.

ANSWER (A)

Omitting the fifth step (carrying over) leads to incorrect addition results because the newly formed groups of tens, hundreds, etc., are dropped instead of being added to their respective higher place value columns.

(b)PART B

Give examples where the algorithm will work correctly and where it will fail to work without the fifth step.

Step 1 — EXAMPLE WHERE THE ALGORITHM WORKS WITHOUT THE CARRY STEP

Consider adding 2323 and 4242.
+23+42—+65\begin{aligned} & \phantom{+} 23 \\[0.6em] & + 42 \\[0.6em] & \text{---} \\[0.6em] & \phantom{+} 65 \end{aligned}
Adding the units column: 3+2=53 + 2 = 5.
Adding the tens column: 2+4=62 + 4 = 6.
Since neither column sum exceeds 99, no carry is generated. Thus, the algorithm works correctly even if the fifth step is ignored.

Step 2 — EXAMPLE WHERE THE ALGORITHM FAILS WITHOUT THE CARRY STEP

Consider adding 3838 and 4545.
+38+45—+83\begin{aligned} & \phantom{+} 38 \\[0.6em] & + 45 \\[0.6em] & \text{---} \\[0.6em] & \phantom{+} 83 \end{aligned}

  • With the fifth step (Correct): In the units column, 8+5=138 + 5 = 13. We write 33 and carry over 11 to the tens column. In the tens column, 3+4+1(extcarry)=83 + 4 + 1 ( ext{carry}) = 8. The final sum is 8383.
  • Without the fifth step (Incorrect): In the units column, 8+5=138 + 5 = 13, we write 33 and drop the 11. In the tens column, 3+4=73 + 4 = 7. The incorrect result obtained is 7373 instead of 8383.

ANSWER (B)

The algorithm works without the carry step when no column sum reaches 1010 or more (e.g., 23+42=6523 + 42 = 65). It fails when any column sum is 1010 or greater (e.g., 38+4538 + 45), yielding an incorrect smaller sum if the carry is ignored.

COMMON MISTAKES

  • Ignoring Place Value: Forgetting that each column represents a different power of ten (units, tens, hundreds), which is why the carry must shift to the left column.
  • Dropping Digits: Simply discarding the extra digit generated in a column sum instead of adding it as a carry.

Was this solution helpful?

Quick Concept Check: Test Your Understanding

Interactive self-testing widget

?
What is the primary purpose of carrying over a digit in the standard addition algorithm?