Q3: (i) In a quadrilateral , suppose . Can be non‑convex? (ii) What if we instead assume ? (iii) What if we instead assume ?
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
- We need to analyze whether a quadrilateral can be non-convex under three different given conditions:
- A convex quadrilateral has all its interior angles strictly less than and both diagonals lie entirely inside the figure. A non-convex (or concave) quadrilateral has one interior angle greater than (reflex angle) and one vertex pointing inwards, with at least one diagonal lying outside the figure.
(i)PART I
In a quadrilateral , suppose . Can be non-convex?Step 1 — ANALYZE THE CONDITION
A quadrilateral has . We can construct a non-convex quadrilateral where one vertex (say or ) is pushed inwards such that the interior angle at that vertex becomes greater than , while keeping the opposite sides and parallel.
Step 2 — VERIFY NON-CONVEXITY PROPERTIES
By sketching such a figure, one of the interior angles is a reflex angle () and one of the diagonals falls outside the region enclosed by the boundary of the quadrilateral. Thus, a quadrilateral with can indeed be non-convex (e.g., an arrowhead-like or self-intersecting-free concave shape with parallel opposite sides).
ANSWER (I)
Yes, a quadrilateral with can be non-convex.
(ii)PART II
What if we instead assume ?Step 1 — ANALYZE THE CONDITION
We are given that one pair of opposite sides is equal in length (). We need to determine if a non-convex quadrilateral can be formed with this property.
Step 2 — CONSTRUCT A COUNTER-EXAMPLE OR VERIFY EXISTENCE
By taking two segments of equal length and and connecting their endpoints to and to in such a way that one vertex is indented inwards (reflex angle ), we form a valid concave (non-convex) quadrilateral where .
ANSWER (II)
Yes, a quadrilateral with can be non-convex.
(iii)PART III
What if we instead assume ?Step 1 — ANALYZE THE CONDITION
We are given that a pair of opposite angles are equal (). We need to check if a non-convex quadrilateral can satisfy this.
Step 2 — CONSTRUCT A NON-CONVEX CONFIGURATION
In a non-convex quadrilateral, one interior angle is a reflex angle (). If we position the vertices such that one reflex angle and one standard interior angle are equal (or if two acute/obtuse interior angles equal each other while one vertex is reflex), we can satisfy while maintaining a concave shape.
ANSWER (III)
Yes, a quadrilateral with can be non-convex.
COMMON MISTAKES
- Confusing Convex and Non-Convex: Assuming all quadrilaterals must have interior angles strictly less than .
- Ignoring Concave Shapes: Failing to visualize shapes with a 'dent' or a reflex interior angle where diagonals fall outside the boundary.