Q4: Consider three non‑collinear points , , and draw the lines , , . For every possible location of point in the plane outside these lines, decide whether the quadrilateral is self‑intersecting, non‑convex, or convex. (Hint: the three lines divide the plane into regions.)
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
- We are given three non-collinear points , , in a plane which determine the lines , , and .
- These three lines of a triangle divide the entire plane into distinct regions (1 interior region and 6 exterior regions).
- A point is chosen in the plane outside these lines to form a quadrilateral .
- We need to analyze the nature of the quadrilateral (convex, non-convex, or self-intersecting) depending on which of the regions point lies in, using fundamental geometric definitions of polygons from Class 9 NCERT geometry.
Step 1 — ANALYZE THE 7 REGIONS FORMED BY THE THREE LINES
When three non-collinear lines (the sides extended infinitely) intersect at three points , , and , they divide the plane into regions:
- Region 1 (Interior): The interior of .
- Regions 2, 3, 4 (Exterior adjacent to edges): Three unbounded regions lying opposite to vertices , , and across the sides , , and respectively.
- Regions 5, 6, 7 (Vertically opposite / wedge regions): Three unbounded regions lying directly opposite to vertices , , and through the intersections.
Step 2 — CASE 1: POINT LIES IN THE INTERIOR OF (REGION 1)
If point is inside , the line segments connecting to the vertices intersect the sides of the triangle, or when we trace the boundary in order , the sides cross over each other.
Specifically, a quadrilateral is called convex if all its interior angles are strictly less than and both of its diagonals lie entirely inside the figure. If is inside , the quadrilateral is non-convex (or concave), because one of the interior angles at vertex reflex-exceeds , and the diagonals intersect outside or the vertices wrap inward.
Step 3 — CASE 2: POINT LIES IN THE THREE EXTERIOR REGIONS OPPOSITE TO THE SIDES (REGIONS 2, 3, 4)
If point lies in the exterior region adjacent to side (opposite to vertex ), side crosses line . Tracing the order results in intersecting sides.
Therefore, when point is located in any of the three exterior regions adjacent directly across the three sides of the triangle, the quadrilateral is self-intersecting (a crossed quadrilateral where two opposite sides intersect).
Step 4 — CASE 3: POINT LIES IN THE THREE EXTERIOR WEDGE REGIONS OPPOSITE TO THE VERTICES (REGIONS 5, 6, 7)
If point lies in the region vertically opposite to vertex (beyond the intersection of the two lines meeting at ), or similarly for vertices and , point lies outside the triangle such that the resulting figure has all interior angles less than and no sides intersect.
Therefore, when point is located in one of these three exterior regions, the quadrilateral is convex.
ANSWER
Out of the regions:
- 1 region (Interior of the triangle): The quadrilateral is non-convex (concave).
- 3 regions (Exterior regions adjacent to the sides): The quadrilateral is self-intersecting.
- 3 regions (Exterior regions opposite to the vertices): The quadrilateral is convex.
COMMON MISTAKES
- Confusing Interior and Exterior: Assuming all points outside the triangle form convex quadrilaterals without testing the order of vertices and line intersections.
- Ignoring Self-Intersection: Failing to recognize that if a point causes the line segments forming the perimeter to cross each other, the shape is a self-intersecting polygon rather than a simple quadrilateral.