Q3: You know that the sum of the interior angles of a quadrilateral is , even for a non‑convex quadrilateral. (Recall the proof.) Now consider a self‑intersecting quadrilateral , where and intersect at point . Show that . Can you construct such that ?
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
The problem asks to prove that for a self‑intersecting (crossed) quadrilateral the sum of the four interior angles is strictly less than , and then to show that a quadrilateral can be drawn whose angle sum is as small as . The proof uses only the Class 9 concepts: (i) sum of interior angles of a triangle is , (ii) vertical angles are equal, and (iii) basic angle addition.
Step 1 — DRAW THE CROSSED QUADRILATERAL AND MARK THE INTERSECTION
Let the sides and intersect at . The four interior angles of the quadrilateral are the angles at the vertices that lie inside the figure. At four angles are formed; denote the acute one by and the obtuse one by . By the vertical‑angle theorem (NCERT Chapter 2, §2.2) we have
Step 2 — APPLY THE TRIANGLE‑ANGLE‑SUM THEOREM TO TWO SUITABLE TRIANGLES
Consider triangles and . Each is a simple triangle, so by the triangle‑angle‑sum theorem (NCERT Chapter 2, §2.1)
Here and (vertical angles).
Step 3 — ADD THE TWO EQUATIONS
Adding the two equalities obtained above gives
Step 4 — DERIVE THE REQUIRED INEQUALITY
Since is a positive angle (the interior angle at the intersection), . Rearranging the previous relation we obtain
Because is subtracted from , we have
Step 5 — CHOOSE A VALUE OF TO OBTAIN A SUM OF
From the formula , set the sum equal to :
Thus we need the acute angle at to be (i.e., the two intersecting lines are almost collinear).
Step 6 — CONSTRUCTION OF THE REQUIRED QUADRILATERAL
- Draw a straight line .
- Draw another line through a point on such that the angle between and is (use a protractor to mark a very small deviation of from a straight line).
- Choose a point on to the left of and a point on above .
- Choose a point on to the right of and a point on below .
- Connect to , to , to , and to . The resulting quadrilateral is self‑intersecting with and meeting at .
Because , the formula gives
ANSWER
For any self‑intersecting quadrilateral , where is the acute angle formed by the intersecting sides. By choosing we obtain Hence such a quadrilateral can indeed be constructed.
COMMON MISTAKES
- Treating the crossed quadrilateral as a simple quadrilateral: The rule applies only to non‑self‑intersecting quadrilaterals. For a crossed one we must use triangles formed by the intersection point.
- Confusing the vertical angles: The two opposite angles at are equal; forgetting this leads to an incorrect sum.
- Assuming can be : must be a positive angle; otherwise the figure would degenerate into a straight line.