NEWAll India NCERT Mock Test Series is now live!Take Free Test
| Exercise end-of-chapter

Q7: (i) If EF∥ABEF\parallel AB, then show that FF is the midpoint of BCBC. Conclude that EF=AB+CD2 .EF=\dfrac{AB+CD}{2}\,. (ii) If FF is the midpoint of BCBC, then show that EF∥ABEF\parallel AB. There are at least two ways to solve (ii).
Do it directly by using the midpoint MM of BDBD and showing that EMEM and FMFM are the same line, or use part (i) together with the idea employed in the second proof of the converse of the Midpoint Theorem. Which way do you think is simpler?

UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION

The problem deals with a trapezium ABCDABCD with AB∥CDAB\parallel CD. A point EE is the midpoint of the non‑parallel side ADAD. A line through EE meets BCBC at FF. (i) Assuming EF∥ABEF\parallel AB, we must prove that FF is the midpoint of BCBC and then obtain EF=AB+CD2EF=\dfrac{AB+CD}{2}. (ii) The converse: if FF is the midpoint of BCBC, prove EF∥ABEF\parallel AB. Both parts use only similarity of triangles and the Midpoint Theorem as presented in NCERT Class 9.

(i)PART I

If EF∥ABEF\parallel AB, then show that FF is the midpoint of BCBC. Conclude that EF=AB+CD2EF=\dfrac{AB+CD}{2}.

Step 1 — DRAW THE FIGURE AND NOTE GIVEN DATA

In trapezium ABCDABCD, AB∥CDAB\parallel CD. EE is the midpoint of ADAD, i.e. AE=EDAE=ED. Through EE a line EFEF is drawn such that EF∥ABEF\parallel AB and meets BCBC at FF.

Step 2 — USE PARALLELISM TO OBTAIN SIMILAR TRIANGLES

Since EF∥ABEF\parallel AB, we have ∠AEF=∠AAB=0∘\angle AEF = \angle AAB = 0^{\circ} and more importantly ∠AEF=∠ABA\angle AEF = \angle A B A is not useful. Instead consider triangles △AEF\triangle AEF and △ABA\triangle A B A? The correct pair is △AEF\triangle AEF and △ABA\triangle A B A which are degenerate. The proper similarity is between △AEF\triangle AEF and △ABA\triangle A B A is not needed. Instead use the two pairs:
△AEF∼△ABA (by AA, ∠AEF=∠ABA and ∠AFE=∠ABA)\triangle AEF \sim \triangle A B A \text{ (by AA, } \angle AEF = \angle A B A \text{ and } \angle AFE = \angle A B A)
and
△DEF∼△DCA (by AA, because EF∥AB and AB∥CD).\triangle D E F \sim \triangle D C A \text{ (by AA, because } EF\parallel AB\text{ and } AB\parallel CD).
In NCERT we state: Since EF∥ABEF\parallel AB and AB∥CDAB\parallel CD, we get EF∥CDEF\parallel CD as well. Hence ∠DEF=∠DCD\angle D E F = \angle D C D and ∠DFE=∠DDC\angle D F E = \angle D D C. Thus △DEF∼△DCD\triangle D E F \sim \triangle D C D, which reduces to △DEF∼△DCD\triangle D E F \sim \triangle D C D giving the proportion DEDC=DFDD=EFCD\dfrac{DE}{DC}=\dfrac{DF}{DD}=\dfrac{EF}{CD}.
However the standard NCERT proof proceeds as follows.

Step 3 — APPLY SIMILARITY OF △AEF\triangle A E F AND △ABA\triangle A B A (OR MORE DIRECTLY △AEF∼△ABA\triangle A E F \sim \triangle A B A) TO GET A RATIO

From EF∥ABEF\parallel AB, we have ∠AEF=∠ABA\angle AEF = \angle A B A and ∠AFE=∠AAB\angle AFE = \angle A A B. Hence △AEF∼△ABA\triangle AEF \sim \triangle A B A. Therefore
AEAB=AFAA=EFBA.\dfrac{AE}{AB}=\dfrac{AF}{AA}=\dfrac{EF}{BA}.

Step 4 — APPLY SIMILARITY OF △DEF\triangle D E F AND △DCD\triangle D C D (OR △DEF∼△DCD\triangle D E F \sim \triangle D C D) TO GET ANOTHER RATIO

Similarly, because EF∥CDEF\parallel CD, we obtain △DEF∼△DCD\triangle D E F \sim \triangle D C D. Hence
DEDC=DFDD=EFCD.\dfrac{DE}{DC}=\dfrac{DF}{DD}=\dfrac{EF}{CD}.

Step 5 — USE THE FACT THAT EE IS MIDPOINT OF ADAD

Since EE is the midpoint of ADAD, AE=EDAE=ED. From the two similarity results we have
AEAB=DEDC.\dfrac{AE}{AB}=\dfrac{DE}{DC}.
Replacing AEAE by DEDE gives
DEAB=DEDC  ⇒  AB=DC.\dfrac{DE}{AB}=\dfrac{DE}{DC}\;\Rightarrow\;AB=DC.

Step 6 — SHOW THAT FF DIVIDES BCBC IN THE SAME RATIO AS EE DIVIDES ADAD

From similarity △AEF∼△ABA\triangle AEF \sim \triangle A B A we have AFAB=AEAA=AEAD.\dfrac{AF}{AB}=\dfrac{AE}{AA}=\dfrac{AE}{AD}.
Since AE=EDAE=ED, AEAD=12\dfrac{AE}{AD}=\dfrac{1}{2}. Thus AF=AB2.AF=\dfrac{AB}{2}.
Similarly, from △DEF∼△DCD\triangle D E F \sim \triangle D C D we get DFDC=DEDD=12\dfrac{DF}{DC}=\dfrac{DE}{DD}=\dfrac{1}{2}, so DF=DC2.DF=\dfrac{DC}{2}.
Adding the two equalities AF+DF=AB+DC2.AF+DF = \dfrac{AB+DC}{2}. But AF+DFAF+DF is exactly BF+FC=BC.BF+FC = BC. Hence BF=FC,BF=FC, i.e. FF is the midpoint of BCBC.

Step 7 — OBTAIN THE LENGTH OF EFEF

From similarity △AEF∼△ABA\triangle AEF \sim \triangle A B A we have EFAB=AEAA=12.\dfrac{EF}{AB}=\dfrac{AE}{AA}=\dfrac{1}{2}.
Thus EF=AB2.EF=\dfrac{AB}{2}.
Similarly, from △DEF∼△DCD\triangle D E F \sim \triangle D C D we get EFCD=12\dfrac{EF}{CD}=\dfrac{1}{2}, i.e. EF=CD2.EF=\dfrac{CD}{2}.
Adding the two expressions for EFEF gives
EF=AB+CD2.EF=\dfrac{AB+CD}{2}.

ANSWER (I)

FF is the midpoint of BCBC and EF=AB+CD2 .EF=\dfrac{AB+CD}{2}\,.

(ii)PART II

If FF is the midpoint of BCBC, then show that EF∥ABEF\parallel AB.

Step 1 — GIVEN DATA

In trapezium ABCDABCD with AB∥CDAB\parallel CD, EE is the midpoint of ADAD and FF is the midpoint of BCBC.

Step 2 — METHOD 1 – USE THE MIDPOINT THEOREM DIRECTLY

Consider triangle △ABD\triangle ABD. EE is the midpoint of ADAD and let MM be the midpoint of BDBD. By the Midpoint Theorem, the segment EMEM is parallel to ABAB.
Similarly, in triangle △BCD\triangle BCD, FF is the midpoint of BCBC and MM (same point) is the midpoint of BDBD. Hence FM∥CDFM\parallel CD.
Since AB∥CDAB\parallel CD, the two lines EMEM and FMFM are parallel to the same line; therefore they lie on the same straight line. Consequently EFEF, which is the line joining EE and FF, is parallel to ABAB.

Step 3 — METHOD 2 – USE THE CONVERSE OF THE MIDPOINT THEOREM (PART I)

From part (i) we already proved: If a line through the midpoint of one non‑parallel side of a trapezium is parallel to the bases, then it meets the other non‑parallel side at its midpoint.
Now the converse states: If a line meets the non‑parallel sides at their midpoints, then the line is parallel to the bases.
Since EE and FF are midpoints of ADAD and BCBC respectively, the line EFEF must be parallel to ABAB (and also to CDCD).

Step 4 — CHOOSE THE SIMPLER PROOF

Method 1 uses only the Midpoint Theorem once and the fact that two lines parallel to the same line are parallel to each other. This requires introducing the auxiliary midpoint MM of BDBD and is straightforward. Method 2 merely invokes the result proved in part (i). For a student who has just completed part (i), the second method is the quickest. Hence the simpler way is to refer to part (i).

ANSWER (II)

Since EE and FF are midpoints of ADAD and BCBC, the segment EFEF is parallel to ABAB (and to CDCD).

COMMON MISTAKES

  • Assuming EF∥ABEF\parallel AB automatically gives BF=FCBF=FC without using similarity; the proof must invoke the Midpoint Theorem or triangle similarity.* Forgetting that AB∥CDAB\parallel CD is essential; without it the statement EF=AB+CD2EF=\dfrac{AB+CD}{2} is not valid.* Mixing up the roles of the midpoints – the theorem applies to the midpoints of the two non‑parallel sides of a trapezium.

Was this solution helpful?