Q7: (i) If , then show that is the midpoint of . Conclude that
(ii) If is the midpoint of , then show that . There are at least two ways to solve (ii).
Do it directly by using the midpoint of and showing that and are the same line, or use part (i) together with the idea employed in the second proof of the converse of the Midpoint Theorem. Which way do you think is simpler?
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
The problem deals with a trapezium with . A point is the midpoint of the non‑parallel side . A line through meets at . (i) Assuming , we must prove that is the midpoint of and then obtain . (ii) The converse: if is the midpoint of , prove . Both parts use only similarity of triangles and the Midpoint Theorem as presented in NCERT Class 9.
(i)PART I
If , then show that is the midpoint of . Conclude that .Step 1 — DRAW THE FIGURE AND NOTE GIVEN DATA
In trapezium , . is the midpoint of , i.e. . Through a line is drawn such that and meets at .
Step 2 — USE PARALLELISM TO OBTAIN SIMILAR TRIANGLES
Since , we have and more importantly is not useful. Instead consider triangles and ? The correct pair is and which are degenerate. The proper similarity is between and is not needed. Instead use the two pairs:
and
In NCERT we state: Since and , we get as well. Hence and . Thus , which reduces to giving the proportion .
However the standard NCERT proof proceeds as follows.
Step 3 — APPLY SIMILARITY OF AND (OR MORE DIRECTLY ) TO GET A RATIO
From , we have and . Hence . Therefore
Step 4 — APPLY SIMILARITY OF AND (OR ) TO GET ANOTHER RATIO
Similarly, because , we obtain . Hence
Step 5 — USE THE FACT THAT IS MIDPOINT OF
Since is the midpoint of , . From the two similarity results we have
Replacing by gives
Step 6 — SHOW THAT DIVIDES IN THE SAME RATIO AS DIVIDES
From similarity we have
Since , . Thus
Similarly, from we get , so
Adding the two equalities But is exactly Hence i.e. is the midpoint of .
Step 7 — OBTAIN THE LENGTH OF
From similarity we have
Thus
Similarly, from we get , i.e.
Adding the two expressions for gives
ANSWER (I)
is the midpoint of and
(ii)PART II
If is the midpoint of , then show that .Step 1 — GIVEN DATA
In trapezium with , is the midpoint of and is the midpoint of .
Step 2 — METHOD 1 – USE THE MIDPOINT THEOREM DIRECTLY
Consider triangle . is the midpoint of and let be the midpoint of . By the Midpoint Theorem, the segment is parallel to .
Similarly, in triangle , is the midpoint of and (same point) is the midpoint of . Hence .
Since , the two lines and are parallel to the same line; therefore they lie on the same straight line. Consequently , which is the line joining and , is parallel to .
Step 3 — METHOD 2 – USE THE CONVERSE OF THE MIDPOINT THEOREM (PART I)
From part (i) we already proved: If a line through the midpoint of one non‑parallel side of a trapezium is parallel to the bases, then it meets the other non‑parallel side at its midpoint.
Now the converse states: If a line meets the non‑parallel sides at their midpoints, then the line is parallel to the bases.
Since and are midpoints of and respectively, the line must be parallel to (and also to ).
Step 4 — CHOOSE THE SIMPLER PROOF
Method 1 uses only the Midpoint Theorem once and the fact that two lines parallel to the same line are parallel to each other. This requires introducing the auxiliary midpoint of and is straightforward. Method 2 merely invokes the result proved in part (i). For a student who has just completed part (i), the second method is the quickest. Hence the simpler way is to refer to part (i).
ANSWER (II)
Since and are midpoints of and , the segment is parallel to (and to ).
COMMON MISTAKES
- Assuming automatically gives without using similarity; the proof must invoke the Midpoint Theorem or triangle similarity.* Forgetting that is essential; without it the statement is not valid.* Mixing up the roles of the midpoints – the theorem applies to the midpoints of the two non‑parallel sides of a trapezium.