Q7: (i) Compare the solutions of the equations and . Argue that they have the same set of solutions, that is, every solution of one is also a solution of the other. (ii) Show that the equations and , with , have the same set of solutions.
UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION
- Part (i) asks to compare two linear equations and show that they represent the same line, i.e., they have identical solution sets. * Part (ii) generalises the idea: multiplying a linear equation by a non‑zero constant does not change its set of solutions. * The NCERT concepts used are: linear equations in two variables, the notion of proportional (or equivalent) equations, and the property that multiplying an equation by a non‑zero constant yields an equivalent equation.
(i)PART I
Compare the solutions of the equations and . Argue that they have the same set of solutions, that is, every solution of one is also a solution of the other.Step 1 — WRITE THE TWO EQUATIONS
The given equations are and
Step 2 — OBSERVE THAT (2) IS A MULTIPLE OF (1)
Multiply equation (1) by the non‑zero constant :
which simplifies to exactly equation (2).
Step 3 — SHOW A SOLUTION OF (1) SATISFIES (2)
Let be any ordered pair that satisfies (1), i.e. . Multiplying both sides by gives , which is precisely the condition for to satisfy (2). Hence every solution of (1) is a solution of (2).
Step 4 — SHOW A SOLUTION OF (2) SATISFIES (1)
Conversely, let satisfy (2): . Since , we can divide both sides by to obtain , which is equation (1). Thus every solution of (2) is also a solution of (1).
Step 5 — CONCLUSION FOR PART (I)
Because each solution of one equation is a solution of the other, the two equations have exactly the same set of solutions; they represent the same straight line in the ‑plane.
ANSWER (I)
The equations and are equivalent; they have the same set of solutions.
(ii)PART II
Show that the equations and , with , have the same set of solutions.Step 1 — STATE THE TWO GENERAL EQUATIONS
Consider and where is a non‑zero constant.
Step 2 — DERIVE (2) FROM (1)
Multiplying equation (1) by (which is allowed because ) gives i.e. which is exactly equation (2).
Step 3 — SOLUTION OF (1) SATISFIES (2)
If a pair satisfies (1), then . Multiplying both sides by yields , so also satisfies (2).
Step 4 — SOLUTION OF (2) SATISFIES (1)
If satisfies (2), then . Since , divide the whole equation by to obtain , which is equation (1). Hence is also a solution of (1).
Step 5 — CONCLUSION FOR PART (II)
Every solution of one equation is a solution of the other; therefore the equations and (with ) have identical solution sets.
ANSWER (II)
The two equations are equivalent; they possess the same set of solutions.
COMMON MISTAKES
- Forgetting that must be non‑zero; dividing by zero would be invalid. * Assuming that multiplying only one side of the equation (e.g., only the left‑hand side) keeps the solutions unchanged – the whole equation must be multiplied by the same non‑zero constant. * Confusing proportional coefficients with different lines; proportional coefficients together with a proportional constant term guarantee the same line.